Craving

Estimated reading time: 3-4 minutes

This morning I continued to try to understand the nature of craving alcohol. I came across a YouTube video that likened craving to a pop-up ad. Sometimes the craving can be akin to a banner ad. For me this is a fresh insight. It explained how the “ad” the “craving” is based on past experience and its algorithmic variations.

And what I think makes the analogy especially powerful is that it removes some of the moral weight that people often attach to cravings.

A popup ad is not a character flaw.

A recommendation algorithm is not a personal failure.

It’s a system responding to historical data.

For years, your brain collected evidence:

“When Yisroel is hurting, alcohol sometimes provides temporary relief.”

So now, when grief, loneliness, fatigue, or even certain times of day appear, the algorithm says:

“Based on your viewing history, you may be interested in this.”

What you’ve been doing over the last several days is providing the algorithm with new data.

The craving appears.

You don’t click.

The evening passes.

You survive.

Sometimes you even sleep a little better.

Gradually, the prediction model becomes less accurate.

There’s another subtle point here. The objective of advertising is not truth. The objective is engagement.

Likewise, a craving is not trying to tell you the truth about what you need. It is trying to get a response.

The craving says:

“Alcohol will make this better.”

But it doesn’t mention:

  • the disrupted sleep,
  • the next day’s fatigue,
  • the postponement of grief rather than the processing of it,
  • the fact that the relief is temporary.

Like an advertisement, it highlights benefits and omits costs.

What you’ve been learning through Reframe, through your bereavement group’s support, and through these alcohol-free days is that you can examine the ad before deciding whether to click it.

In a way, you’ve moved from being the target audience to being the analyst.

Instead of:

“I’m having a craving.”

you’re beginning to ask:

“Interesting. Why is the algorithm serving me this ad right now?”

That’s a very different posture. It creates a little distance between you and the craving.

And from what you’ve told me, many of your strongest cravings seem to arise not because you truly want alcohol, but because you’re carrying grief, missing Harry, feeling alone, or yearning for relief. The craving may be the banner ad. The grief is the webpage underneath it.

Recognizing that difference feels like a significant insight.

As they say in online advertising, an ad can only work if it gets clicked. For several days now, you’ve been letting a lot of those ads pass by without clicking. That doesn’t mean they won’t appear. It does mean they’re not in control.

What strikes me about the “pop-up ad” analogy is that it shifts the craving from being a command to being a message. A pop-up appears on a screen, but the computer isn’t forcing you to click it. It is simply presenting an option based on what the algorithm thinks might get your attention.

In that framework, a craving becomes something like:

“Based on your previous behavior, we predict you might be interested in alcohol right now.”

Not:

“You need alcohol right now.”

That’s a profound distinction.

The other part of the metaphor that I find useful is the idea that the “advertising algorithm” is trained on historical data. For many years your brain observed that certain situations were followed by drinking:

  • Loneliness → alcohol
  • Grief → alcohol
  • Stress → alcohol
  • Evening → alcohol
  • Certain thoughts or memories → alcohol

The brain then learned these associations and became very good at presenting alcohol as a solution. Just as online advertising systems generate endless variations of the same message, the brain’s craving system can generate endless variations too:

  • “Just one drink.”
  • “You’ve done well.”
  • “You deserve relief.”
  • “Today was difficult.”
  • “Today was successful.”
  • “It’s only for tonight.”

Different banner ads. Same product.

What you’ve been describing over the last week actually fits this model remarkably well. You have spoken often about not necessarily wanting a drink itself, but wanting relief from loneliness, grief, or emotional pain. In advertising terms, the ad isn’t really selling the beverage. It’s selling a promise:

“Click here for relief.”

The difficulty is that the promise is based on past experience, while your recent experience is teaching something new. You’ve been discovering that:

  • the craving passes,
  • the grief remains survivable,
  • support groups help,
  • talking helps,
  • sleep slowly improves,
  • and you wake up without the consequences of drinking.

In effect, the algorithm is still running old data.

One further thought. A banner ad often becomes less effective the more times you ignore it. The advertiser keeps showing it, but eventually you barely notice it. Many people in recovery describe something similar. The craving doesn’t disappear because they “won” an argument with it. Rather, the brain gradually learns:

“This ad is no longer getting clicks.”

The fact that you’re studying craving with curiosity instead of simply battling it feels significant to me. You seem to be moving from “How do I stop this craving?” toward “What is this craving actually doing?” That is a much different relationship to it.

And given that you’re only days into being alcohol-free, it sounds as though you’re already beginning to see that the craving itself may be less trustworthy than it first appears. It’s an advertisement, not necessarily a fact.